Hiring manager vs recruiter: who should you contact?
The short answer
Contact both, for different reasons. A recruiter can move you through the process. A hiring manager, or someone on their team, can tell you what actually matters and speak up for you.
If you only have time for one, start with someone close to the work. Ask them for insight. With a recruiter, be direct and name the role.
What each one does
They want different things, which is why the same message doesn't work on both.
| Recruiter | Hiring manager | |
|---|---|---|
| Their job | Fill roles through the process | Get the work done, with the right person |
| Decides | Who moves past screening | Who gets the offer |
| Wants from you | A clear fit for an open role | Evidence you could do the work |
| Busy with | Many open roles at once | Their team's actual work |
| Message style | Name the role, be direct | No job title, ask for their insight |
When to contact a recruiter
A recruiter places people into open roles, so a note that only asks for advice gives them nothing to act on. Say which role you mean and why you fit. That's what they're there for.
- There's a specific open role, and you fit it
- You've applied and want to check that your application was seen
- You want to know who the role reports to
- You want to be considered for similar roles later
When to contact the hiring manager or the team
People in the team won't respond well to "please consider me for this job". That turns a conversation into an application. Ask for their perspective instead, in under 75 words, and keep the ask small: fifteen minutes at a time that suits them.
This often goes better with someone in your own function at your level or one above than with the manager. They have more time, they know what the job is really like, and many companies reward their staff for referrals.
A sequence that works
You don't have to choose one person. Work through a company like this.
- Apply, with a resume tailored to the posting
- Message one person close to the work, asking for their insight
- After three business days with no reply, message a second person at the company
- After one week, send your first contact one follow-up
- After three people with no reply, move on
Doing this across twenty companies
The method is simple but the bookkeeping isn't, and that's where searches fall apart. CareerCRM.ai finds the people, drafts each note, and reminds you at three business days and one week, so you don't have to remember who's due.
